Balancing Bankability and Investability in Battery and Hybrid Projects

Key points
- Greater bankability doesn’t necessarily make a project more investable.
- Tolling agreements, revenue floors, financial swaps and shaped PPAs can provide greater revenue certainty and help developers secure debt financing on more attractive terms, but this can be at the expense of commercial returns for equity investors.
- A good contracting strategy starts with understanding what a project could earn without any contracted revenue, which depends on its location, market participation opportunities, grid connection, technical characteristics and operating constraints.
- For battery and hybrid projects, technical design, operating strategy and commercial contracting are much more closely interconnected, so developers need an integrated approach to modelling these decisions together.
On this page
- Understanding the underlying market value
- Contracts change more than revenues
- Finding the right balance
- FAQs
- Key terms
- Sources
The flexibility that makes batteries valuable in energy markets also makes their revenues volatile and difficult to predict, which can create challenges for project financing.
As battery markets mature, increasingly sophisticated contracting structures are emerging. Tolling agreements, revenue floors and financial swaps and shaped power purchase agreements (PPAs) can provide greater revenue certainty, helping developers secure debt financing on more attractive terms. But greater bankability doesn’t necessarily make a project more investable.
The investability challenge is to secure sufficient revenue certainty to support financing, without sacrificing the value needed to deliver attractive equity returns.
Understanding the underlying market value
A good contracting strategy starts with understanding what a project could earn without any contracted revenue.
For battery and hybrid projects, this requires more than generic revenue forecasts or estimates of wholesale electricity price spreads. A project’s merchant value depends on its location, market participation opportunities, grid connection, technical characteristics and operating constraints.
Modelling must also reflect realistic operations. Optimisation that assumes perfect knowledge of future prices can materially overstate achievable revenues, while ignoring battery degradation, network constraints or competing market opportunities can produce misleading valuations.
There is also no single correct forecast of future merchant revenue. For example, we know that revenue opportunities change as markets mature and as more batteries enter a market, price spreads and ancillary service prices tend to fall and different forecasts will embed different assumptions regarding the rate of new asset deployment.
While some lenders may have preferences for long-term price forecasts from specific economic consultants (perhaps because of credit teams’ familiarity with specific logos), project developers need a realistic view of the full range of potential outcomes for their investment.
They should be testing different market scenarios, using both historical data and different forward-looking price forecasts to make informed project decisions.
Without credible, project-specific merchant valuations, developers have no reliable basis for assessing the value they’re giving up in a contract.
Contracts change more than revenues
Different contracting structures don’t just re-allocate revenue and risk. They can also fundamentally change how a project operates and how much value it creates.
For example, contracting 50% of a battery’s capacity doesn’t necessarily mean sacrificing 50% of its merchant value. The impact depends on when that capacity is committed, what opportunities exist in other markets and how the remaining flexibility can be used.
For hybrid projects, shaped PPAs introduce further complexity. A battery might be used to firm renewable generation into a contracted delivery profile, but this can restrict opportunities for merchant trading and ancillary services. These interactions can even change the optimal project design, including battery duration, inverter sizing and grid connection capacity.
Historically, renewable project design and PPA contracting have often been managed by different teams using different tools. For traditional wind and solar projects, this separation was relatively straightforward because contracting generally had limited influence on physical operations.
For battery and hybrid projects, technical design, operating strategy and commercial contracting are much more closely interconnected. Developers need an integrated approach to modelling these decisions together, comparing alternative project configurations and contractual arrangements across multiple market scenarios.
Finding the right balance
Contracting more revenue can lengthen debt tenors, reduce financing costs and protect against downside risks. But these benefits need to be weighed against the merchant opportunities being surrendered. Contracting does not necessarily increase how much a project can borrow. An analysis of 27 EU battery financings found that merchant projects raised slightly more debt per MWh than contracted projects, and that the main benefits of contracting were longer loan tenors and lower financing costs. Merchant project finance usually involves less debt at a higher cost, but it can still deliver higher equity returns.
The optimal balance will vary between projects, depending on financing requirements, investor risk appetite and underlying market opportunities. It can also change over time as markets change. Gresham House, for example, had found that toll revenues were well below its worst-case merchant scenario, but signed a toll with Octopus Energy after market revenues fell.
At Gridcog, we help developers and investors evaluate these trade-offs through detailed, site-specific project simulation and dispatch optimisation. Our platform brings together physical project design, market revenue modelling and commercial contract analysis, enabling teams to:
- Establish credible merchant revenue baselines using realistic dispatch optimisation and project-specific operating constraints.
- Compare alternative project designs, contracting structures and proportions of contracted and merchant revenue.
- Test commercial strategies across historical market conditions and multiple forward-looking price scenarios.
- Evaluate how different arrangements affect project revenues and cashflows, providing the inputs needed to assess financing options and equity returns.
By combining these capabilities in a single modelling environment, Gridcog helps technical and commercial teams make informed decisions about project design and contracting strategy.
Ultimately, bankability and investability represent different but closely related objectives. Lenders need confidence that projects can service their debt, while equity investors need attractive risk-adjusted returns.
The goal isn’t simply to maximise contracted revenue or merchant exposure. It’s to find the combination of project design and commercial contracting that makes a project both bankable and investable.
Developing a battery or hybrid project? Get in touch with Gridcog to see how our modelling platform can help you evaluate contracting strategies, optimise project design and build a stronger investment case.
FAQs
Key terms
What does bankability mean?
Whether lenders are willing to provide debt to a project, and on what terms. It depends mainly on how predictable the project’s cashflows are and how well they cover debt repayments.
What does investability mean?
Whether a project offers equity investors a return that is attractive enough for the risk they take on. A project can be bankable but still not investable if contracting away revenue leaves too little return for equity.
What is debt sizing?
The process lenders use to decide how much they will lend, how long the loan runs and what it costs. It is usually based on a conservative view of the project’s cashflows.
What is the debt service coverage ratio (DSCR)?
The cash a project has available to repay debt in a period, divided by the debt repayments due in that period. Lenders set a minimum DSCR, and require a higher one for merchant revenue than for contracted revenue.
What is equity IRR?
The internal rate of return to equity investors after debt has been repaid. It is the main measure investors use to judge whether a project is worth investing in.
What is a risk-adjusted return?
A project’s expected return considered alongside how uncertain that return is.
What is merchant revenue?
Revenue a project earns by selling into energy and ancillary services markets at market prices, without a contract fixing the price.
What is contracted revenue?
Revenue fixed or protected by a contract with a counterparty, such as a tolling agreement, revenue floor, financial swap or shaped PPA.
Sources
- Morgan Lewis, ‘Project Financing Trends for Global Energy Storage Projects in 2026 and Beyond’
- Gridcog, ‘Bankability and the Funding Pathway for BESS and Hybrid Projects’
- Gridcog, ‘Relying on Renewable Energy, Battery Storage and Flex Modelling for Bankable Project Financing’
- Gridcog, ‘Battery Storage Offtake Agreements: Swaps, Floors and Bankability Explained’
- Apricum, ‘How much can a battery project borrow in the EU?’
- pv magazine USA, ‘Battery energy storage revenues for ancillary services fall nearly 90% in ERCOT’
- Energy-Storage.news, ‘“Merchant will keep the most upside”: Europe’s move to tolling agreements for battery storage in focus’
- Gridcog, 'How Revenue Certainty Shapes Debt Capacity for Renewable Energy and Battery Storage Projects'







